pull down to refresh

In my travels, I've noticed profound differences in how people approach generosity. In Thailand, for instance, it's common to see people giving money to the homeless without hesitation. This is in stark contrast to what I observe back home in the States, where such acts of kindness are rare. This disparity made me reflect on the broader concept of change and how we often desire it without being willing to initiate it ourselves.
We frequently wish for change, hoping or even complaining about the need for it. However, we are rarely willing to take the first step toward making that change. The truth is, meaningful change always begins with us. We cannot expect the world to change on its own; change requires a conscious, deliberate decision to grow and improve.
Take my experience as a Bitcoiner, for example. I dream of a hyperbitcoinized world, yet I haven't fully committed to the changes necessary to move in that direction. I still use fiat currency, don't run a full node, and don't pay in sats regularly. This is a clear example of how our aspirations for change must be matched by our actions. Changing ourselves is the most effective way to begin transforming our environment. Even if the external world remains the same, our internal environment will have improved, and that's where the real impact lies.
We often talk about change but fail to follow through. I, too, desire a better world, yet I shy away from small gestures like saying hi to strangers. This simple act of acknowledgment can be the first step towards building a habit of kindness. The same goes for giving money to the homeless. It's not about whether they deserve it; it's about the act of kindness and the fulfillment it brings. These small, consistent actions can gradually transform our habits and, eventually, our environment.
Will giving a few dollars to a homeless person end homelessness or world hunger? Probably not. But it's a step in the right direction, much more so than doing nothing at all. Reflecting on the generosity I've witnessed in Thailand, I see that people there don't think twice about helping others, despite having less wealth than those in the West. They live in a developing country, yet their acts of kindness contribute to a generally happier society.
If we want the world to change, or even just a part of our lives to change, we must start with ourselves. Change always begins with us. If we are unwilling to change, nothing around us will ever change. By becoming the change we wish to see, we can gradually create a better world, one small act of kindness at a time.
reply
What a good paradox, it made my day, thanks for sharing.
reply
homeless people don’t need a few dollars they need a home.
Bitcoinless people need Bitcoin.
give Bitcoin
reply
0 sats \ 7 replies \ @gmd 5 Jun
Better to give to a soup kitchen IMO. In these parts cash given in the streets is very likely going to drugs.
reply
I would agree.
I have a hard time trusting the soup kitchen either.
Charities seems to have huge “admin” costs
reply
It never fails - on the surface, so many charities have a good spiel. But whenever you dig down, you uncover all kinds of crap.
I prefer individuals and organizations that are EXPLICITLY pursuing their own interest, as opposed to setting themselves up to be saints. There's less disappointment that way.
I think some organized charities are okay for a while, a couple years maybe. But then they seem to inevitably devolve into either a bureaucratic boondoggle, or start taking government money, or something else happens.
I volunteered many years ago with an organization called the Student Conservation Association, and did some outdoor oriented internships that were really amazing. I looked them up again recently, and they have gone completely, 100% woke. Also of course mandatory covid vaccinations for anyone that has anything to do with them. Very, very disappointing.
reply
This is why I see people donate books to libraries or coats to cost drives or food to food banks. They do not really trust the orgs that they are giving to so they want to maximize the effectiveness of their donation.
I always thought this was passive aggressive until I got a bit older and considered giving away more often
reply
0 sats \ 1 reply \ @gmd 5 Jun
At least with the food banks you can see them physically delivering product, consistently every day. Who knows with most other non-profits.
reply
Even so - maybe I'm too much of a skeptic - I don't think they're always doing good, or even frequently.
For instance, I once volunteered at a soup kitchen, with a friend who organized the whole meal, once a month. It was "fried chicken" day, they got fried chicken and sides from a local restaurant.
Some of my problems with it were:
  • The majority of the people that came for this free fried chicken dinner were obese, some very much so. They often went through the line 2 or 3 times.
  • None of the patrons was learning to cook, or to take care of anything themselves. Nobody had to do any work or contribute in any way to the dinner. It was all "sit down and be fed".
  • The food was, of course, really unhealthy. And afterwards as many cookies or whatever sweet dessert they offered.
Most of the time, it seems that the charities are run so that the volunteers feel good about themselves. There's a really good book called Toxic Charity by Robert Lupton that fleshes out some of these ideas. Here's a quote:
Almsgiving is Mammon’s perversion of giving. It affirms the superiority of the giver, who thus gains a point on the recipient, binds him, demands gratitude, humiliates him and reduces him to a lower state than he had before.
Charity a perversion? Toxic? That thought clung to me for weeks. Every interaction with low-income neighbors became suspect. I began studying the facial expressions of those I ushered into our church clothes closet. I noticed how seldom recipients gave me direct eye contact. I watched body language as I handed out boxes of groceries from our food pantry—head and shoulders bent slightly forward, self-effacing smiles, meek “thank-yous.” I observed, too, how quickly recipients’ response to charity devolved from gratitude to expectation to entitlement.
In moments of silent introspection, I observed my part in the anatomy of giving: I expected gratitude in exchange for my free gifts. I actually enjoyed occupying the superior position of giver (though I covered it carefully with a facade of humility). I noted a hidden irritation at those who voiced their annoyance when free food stocks ran low. I grew weary of filtering through half-truths and manipulative ploys as I sought to equitably dispense resources. This thorough look at the anatomy of my charity eventually exposed an unhealthy culture of dependency.
With the research intensity of a Louis Pasteur searching for a causal relationship between germs and disease, I examined broader aspects of charity under the microscope of my new awareness. I discovered that the toxins deforming relationships were not confined to our organization or the neighborhood I served. Everywhere I looked, I observed the same patterns, from overseas church mission trips to the inner-city service projects of campus organizations. Wherever there was sustained one-way giving, unwholesome dynamics and pathologies festered under the cover of kindheartedness.
Since that 1981 Christmas Eve, it has baffled me that in a global communication era no watchdog organization warns of the dangers of charity, especially given the growth and popularity of this industry. Now, everyone is getting in on the charity train, from rock groups to youth groups, from TV celebrities to elementary-school children, from Fortune 500 corporations to campus fraternities. And across the board the benevolence business is almost entirely unexamined.
Doing for rather than doing with those in need is the norm. Add to it the combination of patronizing pity and unintended superiority, and charity becomes toxic.
reply
0 sats \ 1 reply \ @gmd 5 Jun
Hmmmm... there should be "Wirecutter" style website that audits non-profits companies that are willing to share their financials and graded by efficiency of their use of funds.
I would think charities with a proven record of efficiency would be willing to be transparent or improve efficiency in order to garner more donations.
This could even make a decent youtube content channel...
🤔
reply
I would watch
reply
If you wanna change the world first change yourself.
reply
I love this. I've always been under the misconception if I give money to the homeless it will end up in their arm somehow. While this may be the case some of the time, I think generally speaking nobody wants to stand outside in the 115-degree Arizona heat all day long. They want what many of us have - 3 square meals, a home, and running water.
This post hit me, as someone who travels alot to - I want to help others who aren't in a situation as fortunate. In the end, we are all humans just wanting to survive and many want to leave the world better than we left it. $5 to me might be small, but it could be the bus fare a person needs to get to their families or feed themselves to survive another day.
reply
10 sats \ 0 replies \ @ChrisS 5 Jun
I have noticed a lot of bitcoiners say they don’t run a full node and I wish that would change. Whatever qualities of Bitcoin that you think you like and wish to see in the world you get none of them(or at least a watered down version) if you don’t run your own node. Still using usd and not paying for everything in Bitcoin is a much larger hurdle to get past. But running a node for some reason is scary to people when all you have to do is download an app on almost any computer and open it.
I’m curious as to why you have not done it yet and what would push you to finally do so?
reply
10 sats \ 0 replies \ @flat24 4 Jun
Wow, it is a quite difficult topic, the culture of the East is very difficult to that of the West as the main complication, and secondly, giving money to others is also something quite controversial and with multiple angles and perspectives to look at it.
For example, here in South America it is common to see people asking for money at traffic lights, train stations, markets, main avenues and among other places, on many occasions they are people of extreme poverty who thanks to that can get something to eat during their day, on other occasions Sometimes they are people with addiction and with this they support their vice, be it gambling, alcohol or drugs, it tends to be generalized that everyone belongs to this second group, but this is not the case and last but not least there is a third group, which are lower class people monetarily speaking but who could easily work and be productive, but No, they decide to act like paupers and in this way they make a living, worthy children of the socialism that the region has adopted in recent decades, even There are countries like Peru, Chile, Ecuador or Colombia where these individuals even generate more money than the average working person who aspires to a minimum wage.
And on the other hand, I totally agree with your words that to see changes we must begin by being ourselves that changed.
thanks for writing about this.
reply
Any little bit of kindness will help the world out. I always hope that my kindness to others will compound down the road, so someone is able to benefit.
reply
10 sats \ 1 reply \ @BTCFC OP 4 Jun
It definitely will friend, without a doubt!
reply
You can only hope and pray.
reply
10 sats \ 1 reply \ @OT 4 Jun
I think Buddhism plays a large part of what you see in Thailand. As a householder it’s your duty to give food or money to monks.
I think in the west it could be that people think every homeless person might be using your money to continue their drug addiction. So then what should you do? Give money to support it? Make a judgment on their appearance to see whether or not they are drug addicts or just homeless? Give food? Or leave it to agencies set up and equipped to help homeless people?
It’s quite a complicated problem
reply
Yes I can see how Buddhism plays a big role in the overall kind culture of the Thai people. The temples were absolutely beautiful to see!
I get what you're saying. Those exact thoughts are what cross my mind every time I see someone on the streets asking for money. But I'm going to try and make an effort to see past that and just be kind without allowing my judgements to prevent me from doing so. Just some self experimentation I guess.
It's a complicated problem, but I feel the answer is a lot more simple than we make it out to be.
I appreciate your perspective!
reply
Change is scary but with every day you make progress. I made many changes some went great others went horribly but like you say be the change you want to see in the world
reply