You don’t need 0s and 1s to perform computations, and in some cases it’s better to avoid them.
Computing today is almost entirely digital. The vast informational catacombs of the internet, the algorithms that power AI, the screen you’re reading this on — all are powered by electronic circuits manipulating binary digits — 0 and 1, off and on. We live, it has been said, in the digital age.
But it’s not obvious why a system that operates using discrete chunks of information would be good at modeling our continuous, analog world. And indeed, for millennia humans have used analog computing devices to understand and predict the ebbs and flows of nature.
Among the earliest known analog computers is the Antikythera mechanism from ancient Greece, which used dozens of gears to predict eclipses and calculate the positions of the sun and moon. Slide rules, invented in the 17th century, executed the mathematical operations that would one day send men to the moon. (The abacus, however, doesn’t count as analog: Its discrete “counters” make it one of the earliest digital computers.) And in the late 19th century, William Thomson, who later became Lord Kelvin, designed a machine that used shafts, cranks and pulleys to model the influence of celestial bodies on the tides. Its successors were used decades later to plan for the beach landings on Normandy on D-Day.
if you're into this kind of thing, there's a pretty good 8and now, se,i.famous) scifi book by Adrian Tchiakowsky, Children of Time, that tells the story of a spider civilization that evolved to form cities and scientists and all that, and they use domesticated ant colonies as analog computers. Also, in Liu's Three Body Problem, a rather central story element is that the civilization on trisolaris employs literal armies to make a circuit board layout to calculate with it. Visualized rather impressively in the (real) show
reply
I think the Three Body Computer was still digital though in that it encoded information in 1s and 0s bits
reply
I remember reading about an ancient Greek device that wouldn't be considered a computer, but did allow them to program and automate the movement of props, curtains, and scenery during theatrical performances.
reply
Even the early electronics where quite différent. I have had to replace the 'logic' that drove the electric motors of a drilling rig built only 35 years ago. About a hundred of buttons and seniors came, as as many wires, 24v or 0v for 1 or 0, in 4 electrical cabinets, each bigger that a fridge. In there, there where hundreds of big old relais, doing all the AND, OR, NOT, boolean operations to combine all those conditions All this for 4 motors. We replaced it by a simple industrial PLC, about the size of à computer, smaller that just the terminals the connect all the inbound and outbound signals. It was fun retro engineering the logical conditions from the relay wiring, then rewriting them
reply
This reminds me of the switchboards they used for telephones. "Operator, what time is it?"
reply