Been thinking the same. Personally I’m a long time iPhone user, but I’m not too happy about Apple forcing AI on users in the coming devices.
As for your question: well GrapheneOS might be discontinued or even forbidden by law. Someone can also cook up a hacked version or an update and spread it due to potential lower levels of due diligence. It may also randomly start to break after an update or make the device less stable due to some not obvious mistake.
I’ll give it a go soon as I’m slowly transitioning to having my own setup for cloud and related stuff.
399 sats \ 0 replies \ @Zk2u 11 Aug
I’ve switched back to iOS from android 3 times now after each attempt going awry. I have a P8P sitting on my desk from the last attempt lol. I hate how you need to use things like profiles to prevent apps from seeing which other apps are installed. iOS won’t let apps do this. Also, choosing a subset of contacts for an app. GrapheneOS makes a big deal out of hardware memory tagging but all system services on iOS, macOS and iPadOS use the same, it’s just Apple never shouted about it. Read through the platform security guide. In my opinion, you get what you pay for with iPhones. Likely a different threat model for me than for y’all of course, but there are annoying things with android itself and just the general lack of quality in many apps available is why I have kept my iPhone every time. All my cloud stuff is self hosted, I’m not using any of their services per se.
As for AI stuff, I respect and trust the way it is implemented. Same way signal built contact verification. “AI” isn’t a problem, it’s mostly just how it’s implemented. I imagine you’ll be able to disable it, I know you definitely can disable ChatGPT which is what I will be doing. Don’t mind the other stuff though, I’ve read their technical documents on how they built it and I approve of the unique design (I’m a systems engineer anyway) they used.
reply
well GrapheneOS might be discontinued or even forbidden by law.
Graphene is basically the same Android everyone uses, but with all the Google stuff stripped away by default and some really good security patches added to make it more secure.
reply
I'm using android for years now with the One plus phones because they where slight cheaper and less bloatware. But they changed this in the last years.
But the topic you mentioned about different profiles is something that would bother me.
I don't have problems with ai, but like you said. It's how they implement it. And for now I don't see why I should have something with ai on my phone
reply
I would recommend reading their article on how they built it, if you’re technically inclined. Attestation method is very similar to how signal scans your contacts for contact discovery privately. https://security.apple.com/blog/private-cloud-compute/
reply