This is based off a continuous three week debate Keyan and I been having on SNL.
Yes35.8%
No55.6%
Let me explain...8.6%
81 votes \ poll ended
I vote yes on the ground that I do not always use terms literally. Listening to a book is not "literally" reading a book but it's close enough to use the same term in most contexts, and in the rare circumstances when the distinction really matters, you can clarify
Also, I think the whole thread so far is this meme
reply
241 sats \ 1 reply \ @anon 8 Sep
it is a form of content and information consumption but it is not.. reading
reply
The important thing though is that the content is the same as the text in the book, just presented in a different form.
It's quite different from watching a movie or listening to a podcast, let alone music.
So technically not reading, but can be considered reading where that technicality is not relevant, because we're more interested in the content than the form, which could include the question "What interesting books have you read recently?" for example.
But if you say "I don't read much these days because it puts a strain on my eyes" then the form is relevant and audiobooks absolutely can't count as reading in this context.
reply
No they count as listening.
However, they do count in terms of consuming a book so it depends if you mean reading literally or not. Since we traditionally use the term read to describe consuming a book I think if you listened to an audiobook you can say "I read that book" to signal you are familiar with it and consumed its contents even though you didn't technically read it, you listened to someone else read it.
Using read to describe consuming an audiobook is akin to addressing a group of people who are not all male as guys. It's just socially understood though not technically correct.
reply
30 sats \ 0 replies \ @Car OP 8 Sep
So sounds like we should start saying culturally, "Yes I've listened to The Mandibles this year and 21 other books but have just read 2."
reply
This I agree with
Half the time when I'm reading, it's verbalized in my head as if it were an audiobook, anyway.
reply
Dense things like "the way" by lao tzu should not be an audiobook, because it requires deeper thinking. But other things are reading, as the thoughts are transmitted.
reply
What happens during the other half?
reply
Either I'm skipping because I don't find it interesting, processing new ideas as a result of the new information, or about 1/4 of the time, i'm reading without verbalizing for some reason.
reply
21 sats \ 0 replies \ @jgbtc 10 Sep
That's interesting. I think I always verbalize in my head.
reply
I agree and I would say fiction is verbalized in my head while nonfiction is words swimming around on a page
reply
same
reply
142 sats \ 0 replies \ @kepford 8 Sep
Here's an observation. Some people have a hard time focusing and absorbing audiobooks. Others like me actually absorb knowledge more readily via audio. I read and listen but I know people that get distracted with audio in ways I do not. I find it more difficult to read and absorb the info.
Know yourself. Do what works. Don't get distracted by what other say is the right method.
reply
10 sats \ 0 replies \ @398ja 8 Sep
I checked the comments before voting, and changed my mind. NO.
reply
no, you're listening but you can still learn from them
reply
Definitely not. You have to read the words, not just hear them. 🤠
reply
61 sats \ 0 replies \ @Golu 9 Sep
Yes, they are not different. They are actually same thing at least in my case. I listen to audiobooks while driving and don't feel much difference if it's slow audio.
reply
It depends upon context! Audiobooks are fantastic for assigned readings or to garner general understanding, and they allow multitasking (driving, gym, housework, etc.). To truly understand and alter your behavior, actually reading is proof of work. True proof of work does not lend itself to significant multitasking.
reply
22 sats \ 0 replies \ @Athena 9 Sep
Feelings are different in both reading and listening. use whatever you like
reply
No it doesn't count as reading. Audio books emphasize the use of your ears therefore it is not considered reading.
reply
For me yes. Because I have tired eyes and cannot read properly on paper or ebook. So I am forced to listen audio books.
reply
do you listen while you work on citadel?
reply
After the sunset, with a beer in my hand, relaxing and watching the work done during the day, thinking also for the next day work to be done.
When the sun goes down, is very quiet and peaceful there, a proper place to listen audio books.
reply
that's the way to do it. What kinda beer are you working with, I have a feeling could be stouts or just regular lager
reply
I love Leffe blonde, belgian beer, 6.6% alc with a nice touch of vanilla. But as a regular one, I like San Miguel, 5.4% alc Both kept fresh in the cold river nearby...
I can only show you the door ... with a Leffe beer 😂😂😂
reply
haha incredible
reply
Audiobooks were a game changer for me when I used to commute. I was able to learn so much. Honestly, what other people think about reading vs listening matters little to me. The point is knowledge building and entertainment. I don't read to impress anyone. I find the type of people that do insufferable.
reply
I retain best watching videos. Then audio. Then reading.
reply
🤣
reply
It is not reading. It's like a friend telling you a story.
Reading engages a different part of your brain.
reply
For me, listening to audiobooks is not something I do without something else going on. I listen to audiobooks when I drive. This way, I can quasi-absorb a book while driving without impairing my ability to drive. It fits in a different place in my head and I gain most of the info in a book. It feels like a good use of time while driving. Driving for me is not something I do for it's own sake. I use it for transportation. Therefore, listening to a book is a good use of the time.
However, my recall of listening to a book is far lower than my recall reading a book. So no. It is not reading.
Also, I never sit still, close my eyes and listen to an audiobook. I would much prefer to read a physical book. I like to reread complex paragraphs and go at my own pace, not the pace set by the narrator.
reply
No. You don't teach people how to listen to audio books. You do teach them how to read.
reply
One could read by candle light before electricity was invented, so no. Also, reading to your children is not the same as your children reading!
reply
10 sats \ 0 replies \ @tolot 8 Sep
Reading is painting in your own imagery the characters, the views, the feelings and sounds and fragrances. You're 100% on it, you can't be anywhere else
You listen to audiobooks when doing something else (most likely) as driving, training or whatever. That is consumption...may be consumption of a good old story, but still consumption.
reply
FUCK YES THEY DO. What if I was blind?
reply
🤣
reply
Pre Bitcoin, Audible save my life
Post Bitcoin, Bitcoin-Audible (By Guy Swann) saved my life
reply
100 sats \ 2 replies \ @j7hB75 8 Sep
I mean, it’s not technically reading but you’re still consuming the same content as if you were reading. I’ve always thought discounting listening to books as silly.
reply
0 sats \ 1 reply \ @Car OP 8 Sep
I actually listen to audio books the same way I listen to records. Complete surrender into experiencing it. Couldn't imagine multitasking while listening to a book.
reply
Depends on what you’re doing while listening. If you’re doing a task that requires little to no mental overhead, like manual labor, then I don’t see a problem.
reply
I would count it. Although it isn’t literally reading, it is in the sense that the data is being uploaded to your brain. Of course, one could say that understanding and retention could be reduced, but at least you can talk to someone about it to a certain extent.
reply
In common usage now, I'd say most people will say they read a book when they listened to the audiobook. I've noticed with a fair number of friends in the past... maybe 5 years or so.
reply
Yes. When your mommy read you a book did you remember it?
reply
21 sats \ 0 replies \ @OT 8 Sep
They do. I've learned so much from audio books over the years. As for retaining info, it might not be as good but you can always listen to the book again while you're doing chores or driving.
reply
audio books count as learning if you pay attention
don't worry about if something counts as reading
reply
Reading and listening are different things.
Quick story
TheWildHustle worked at a bookstore for a couple of years, had a few literary zealots protesting e-books.... they didn't count the e-book as being......a book, and thought their favorite bookstores' life might be in jeopardy. Major bookstores started going out of business shortly afterwards.
End of quick story
reply
Not reading but still a good way to learn and consume material
reply
Of course it counts as reading. It is something that we take for granted if you are using your phonetic loop then it counts similar to reading.
reply
No but it is the only way I can consume books now that I have kids.
reply
No I don't think most of the time audiobook listener even not listining the book they just do their work what they are doing
reply
well despite increasing your potential hearing focus and just closing your eyes i think yeah, it is form of creating and producing such scenarios as you use more power depends on the reader's rhythme i suppose it is better than reading and suits all time long not like actually reading since it would time consuming and your eyes would be all time working besides of that you must always find a good spot to start reading a book not like listening to ot which all time beneficial. hope that helps
reply
Its listening as you use your ears. For reading, you need your eyes to be centred towards the text.
But both provide for the same purpose so, listening and reading are similar here.
For example they are just like a bike and a car. Both are means of transport, however very different but used in the same purpose.
We have five senses. They are very different to each other in many ways. But sometimes, one sense can lead to same result as the other can. For example, the food that smells good will definitely be tasteful.
reply
No no but not at all!! A book is your companion... it is your friend, there is nothing more gratifying than touching its pages and the emotion that is felt when the story is at its most exciting and you gently turn the page and find something different than what your mind imagined!! and that makes you more addicted and you don't want to stop until the story is over!! listening to it is more difficult for you to understand it well... it is like filling your mind with something very valuable to which you are not giving the due respect and attention!!
reply
Count as listening 🎧
reply