pull down to refresh

Most people get the difference between nominal and real.
If your assets/incomes/wages increase from 100 to 105 while general prices in the economy increase by 10%, you had a nominal increase in wages or wealth but a real decrease. You are, economically speaking, worse off – even though, to the great disbelief and confusion of both my mother (https://aier.org/article/money-blindness-and-money-clarity/ ) and my girlfriend, the numbers in your account are bigger.
To confuse people maximally, I therefore sometimes put it this way: The nominal is the real thing you see -- the sticker price; the real is the invisible thing you don’t. Hence “money blindness” or “money illusion.”
While most Bitcoiners understand this in specific examples at the micro level, they often fail to see it in the macro perspective.
This came up beautifully in a long-read from Reason Magazine today (https://reason.com/2024/10/23/the-remarkable-redneck-air-force-of-north-carolina/), about the relief efforts in North Carolina:
This example directly gets to what economists really mean when they say “real.” They don’t merely mean “adjusted for inflation,” but real -- reality, actual, physical -- goods and services. A check for $750 -- or indeed any amount of dollars -- won't do you any good when the stores remain closed or when you can't transact with others. In recent weeks, the people in NC had a real problem, not primarily a monetary problem. (Fair enough, others -- esp along the edges where the regular monetary system still operate -- can turn money into real goods and move them into the disaster area.)
Money is merely a veil between real-world economic transactions, coordinating labor and capital and efforts and investments and all the other financial things we do every day. When you “pay” for something in the store with cash/bank balances/bitcoin, economically speaking you’re “paying” for that with previous efforts (labor, investment returns, gifts from other’s surplus). Goods trade for goods, only with money as a temporary bridge.
More examples: Robert Breedlove and Mike Hobart talked about this in a podcast at length a few years ago (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TI_JPezxecE), emphasizing that bitcoin is amazing for people escaping war zones since they can leave with their assets intact.
That’s a pretty stupid take, as far as things go.
For bitcoin to be used as an asset bridge between [destroyed warzone] and [new refugee home] you must have already had your wealth in bitcoin. Because at the point of a war breaking out or capital controls imposed etc., you will not be able to sell/realize the full value of your physical/captured/stuck assets. = bitcoins' awesome ability to move undetected within a persons head is not the same as moving real goods and services across a border.
The Resistance Money guys (https://aier.org/article/bitcoin-is-resistance-money/) had this observation, too, in an anecdote from Ukraine about a woman named Alina, “a Ukrainian refugee who fled Kyiv with her children in early 2022. Alina’s family stored their wealth in two ways. They had a house, and they had bitcoin. At the time of writing, Alina doesn’t know how that family home is doing; she hasn’t been there for over a year. And there was, of course, no time to sell the home before leaving nor any obvious buyer” (p. 276).
They couldn't "realize" (=make real) the monetary value of their local asset.
All rushing for the exits at once are going to clog the system. If we all flush the toilet at the same time, or unexpectedly turn on all the lights in our houses in the middle of the night, not all will be serviced.
Money -- including on a bitcoin standard -- is just such a system. It coordinates real economic activities.
In a flowy piece from a few years ago, I sarcastically put it this way:
"it took monetary economics many centuries of hard work and laborious testing to figure out that we indeed cannot eat money. Though – and this is the Earth-shattering point – we can trade other things for stuff we can eat, and money is a civilizational-changing vehicle for that, as it moves value both across time and place." https://www.aier.org/article/you-cannot-eat-bitcoin/
THAT’s the real(!) difference between the nominal and the real.
Great Article! Considering material things are also money I wanna take it to another level. Everything is money if you can just posses it. Possession is money. And
reply
A check for $750 -- or indeed any amount of dollars -- won't do you any good when the stores remain closed or when you can't transact with others. In recent weeks, the people in NC had a real problem, not primarily a monetary problem.
Your money is only as real as your ability to buy a good or service with it.
This is why taxing unrealized gains is so insane to me!
How Elon can be a gazillionaire but it was a legit question if he could really offload enough assets to buy Twitter for $40B without tanking the value of those same assets!
reply
aah, if only there were an article, easily accessible, explaining in layman's terms how insane that is! https://aier.org/article/eating-the-rich-wont-feed-the-beast/
reply
Man this Joakim Book guy seems to really know his stuff!
reply
he used to, at least. These days he's merely, like, editing some obscure Bitcoiners and hikes mountains and reviews books #735212 #735212
reply
But what about writing your own book? 😭😭
Will I write my third book before u finish your first?
reply
probably. You're prolific -- and more productive than me even with fam and kids and dog. #self-improvement
reply
Haha! I’ll take the compliment!
Hard to sit still (ironic since you sit to write)
reply
10 sats \ 1 reply \ @siggy47 24 Oct
This reminds me of when I was a kid during the mid 70s gasoline crisis. My dad owned a pharmacy and needed gas for prescription deliveries every day. Gasoline was rationed. You had to wait for your day based on your plate number.Theree was one gas station in the area selling gas at triple the pre crisis price. My job was to keep the delivery cars filled. My father said get the gas, whatever the price. Everyone thought he was an idiot for paying the "price gouger." He said what do I care what they think? We're making money.
reply
nice story -- yeah, we hinge our price estimates at some mental level "OMG gas is $x/gallon" instead of comparing it to a) other prices changing, and b) more importantly for his case, he's making enough/more money at the other end delivering his service
reply
Very important concept. I tell my students, and regular people too:
Stop thinking about money and start thinking about actual things!
Are eggs too expensive? How will giving people more money to buy eggs help if the number of eggs stays the same? 🤔
reply
indeed, indeed
reply
"it took monetary economics many centuries of hard work and laborious testing to figure out that we indeed cannot eat money.
Modern macro theory is still trying to figure this one out.
Great piece!
reply
People dont take into account inflation.
They dont see prices as fluid depending on the supply of money out there.
reply
that's precisely it, sir -- but the point goes waaaay deeper than that
reply
It may go deeper, but if people dont understand the underlying reason, then they wont understand everything beyond that.
reply