pull down to refresh

This is an old article but I thought I would post it since the Health and Fitness Territory is a going concern again.
Canada ranked last among wealthy nations in terms of access to primary care. Only 86% of Canadians have access to a primary care physician. I don't even believe this number. Technically, my family has a primary care physician but she is two hours away in Toronto where we haven't lived for over 3 years now. Not the most ideal situation.
Not to mention if you need a specialist, good luck.
Canada keeps throwing money at the problem but it just keeps getting worse. Besides the obvious rationale that governments aren't good at allocating capital or operating large social programs efficiently, I think there are a few other factors causing this.
Aging population: 50 years ago there were 7.6 times as many working age people as there were senior citizens. Now 3.2. Seniors need much more health care than younger people. This is putting immense pressure on the demand side of the healthcare system.
Immigration: I am not here to make an argument for or against immigration but Canada has increased their intake of immigrants dramatically over the last decade and especially over the last 5 years. For decades, with some variance, Canada was letting in around 0.7% of the population in the form of new immigrants each year. That has been steadily increasing over the past decade and reached 1.2% in 2023. This has added more demand to the system and also some supply of workers but the lead time for supply of health care infrastructure, and educating, training, reskilling workers is much longer than the lead time of someone coming to Canada, obtaining permanent residence and utilizing the healthcare system.
Canada Producing fewer Doctors: Being a doctor is a thankless job in Canada. Canada is only graduating 7.5 new doctors per year per 100,000 people. The OECD average is 14.2. So we are producing new doctors at a much lower rate than other developed nations. On top of that, Canada is doing a very poor job in terms of licensing physicians who were educated abroad (whether they are Canadian citizens or not).
Taxation change: Doctors previously used to be able to save on income taxes by using corporations and holding companies to filter their income through. Around 7 or 8 years ago the government changed the taxation rules for doctors, making their incomes subject to employment income tax rates rather than professional corporation tax rates. There are still some benefits if they have their own practices but the tax rules are much more complex for and less friendly to doctors than they used to be. This caused many older doctors to retire or reduce their working hours and many younger doctors seem to also be choosing more work, life balance and working less days and hours each week.
Classic case of overwhelming demand but not enough ability to create new supply or even the correct incentive structure for existing supply to expand capacity.,
Let's make Canada Healthy Again so we don't need to use the broken system.
Sats for all, GR
I'm pretty sure that this is a self solving problem after they construct the suicide booths.
reply
Well, I would still look at this from a positive side, I mean Canada still does better than many countries globally and remains among the top countries worldwide in terms of healthcare accessibility (I take immigration as a confirmation)
I don't even believe this number. Technically, my family has a primary care physician but she is two hours away in Toronto where we haven't lived for over 3 years now
So, I assume you have tried to find another physician nearby but eventually didn’t manage, is this what you’re saying?
Not to mention if you need a specialist, good luck.
This is a serious problem in many “developed” countries, too.
reply
Yes we have been looking for a local family doctor for years but there are no new practices or current physicians accepting new patients.
reply
At the rate Canada's going, I'd say you're just lucky to still be amongst the "wealthy nations".
Don't worry. You'll be Americans soon enough and then the nightmare of socialized medicine will be over...and you can experience the nightmare of oligopolistic medicine.
reply
Please tell me we can somehow have the worst elements of each. That would be optimal.
reply
You're in luck!
"The worst elements of each." just happens to be America's unofficial slogan.
reply
Awesome.
reply
100 sats \ 1 reply \ @Jer 23h
Something that is not talked about but remains a huge issue is that Family Medicine is implicitly discouraged in medical schools. Save for the very few who are passionate about entering that field: it is generally the fallback for those who cannot handle or cannot afford to specialize. Once you specialize you not only earn more, but you are in complete control of your schedule and quality of life.
Compounding this issue is the allure of wages and perks in the US healthcare system. For instance, my cousin, initially adamant about staying away from US employment as a trauma surgeon, has ended up in his second major city there. His first position not only paid him almost double what he would earn in Canada but also wiped out his student debt, provided a team of immigration consultants to expedite his wife's VISA, secured spots for their kids in a prestigious private school, and housed them in a truly remarkable hospital-owned residence, at about half the market rent.
reply
My cousin is a nurse and she also left Canada some years ago to work in the US. She is the head nurse of an assisted living facility now and has an abundance of nursing staff and other support staff working under her. She also makes a lot more money than she would in Canada. She is also in a low tax state and the municipality she lives in is relatively affordable especially compared to Canadian major cities.
On the flip side, I have a friend whose wife is a doctor and she was practicing in the US but permanently moved to Canada when they got married. So we have at least one on the board. Haha.
reply
You just need trump to "Make Canada Great Again". MCGA doesnt have the right ring as MAGA, though.
reply
Let's make Canada Healthy again first. MCHA. It's great, it's like laughing at McDonalds.
MC HA
reply
Right, make it mandatory to pedal on a bike 2hrs each week. Can you imagine how much energy that would put on to the grid if everyone was required to do that?
reply
This is twice as much better than India. Canada has two doctors for every thousand people. Many are Indians, so immigration is necessary. India produces 70000 doctors every year but half of them go to either Europe, Australia or NA.
The problem imo is that Canada provides so much liberty of practice to doctors. I've read somewhere that half of the doctors are just family doctors, means serving super rich people. Is that corect?
reply
No, I would not say the doctors only serve the super rich. There is not private system. Even if the super rich wanted to hoard all the doctors they could not.
reply
Is private supplemental insurance illegal in Canada?
at least in UK, one can purchase private supplemental insurance
If I were stuck being a doctor in Canada, I would only accept cash patients even if it means being a bootlegger
reply
reply
Ahh ok. So, that was a crap article. But is there a tradition of family doctors?
reply
Time to leave Canada
reply
I'm here to make an argument against immigration and for euthanizing most if not all recent immigrants into Canada, USA, Europe, Japan and S Korea
if we can't kill them I guess we have to deport them
reply
Let's not kill people. I will mark you down as undecided on Canadian immigration. Haha.
My wife is an immigrant to Canada after all. From the US but still an immigrant.
reply
you know me, I only see shades of gray. That was difficult to write w/o laughing, haha.
of course I'm not talking about your wife, immigrants from USA are not the problem in Canada. Migrants from the third world are the problem. Third world problems not first world problems.
We kill the men and enslave the women and children, the western way of deportation
When I said kill I meant euthanasia. But I thought kill was more politically correct
reply