pull down to refresh

Bitcoin is money it is for both spending and saving.
Yes. Agreed. But it only becomes money if it is accepted for goods, AKA spent. If 100% of people saved and never spent, it would have zero economic value.
reply
I don't totally agree with that. It could be used as collateral/reserve asset to underpin the debt based fiat system for quite a long time before being used as a medium of exchange and that would still carry much economic value.
reply
Even then, it's only accepted as collateral or a reserve asset because it can be exchanged (expected to be exchangeable) for other things later, right?
reply
This.
We use the word spend. But it only has fiat value because it's being exchanged ALL THE TIME. If one were to imagine a counterfactual where it was never swapped for fiat (which is crazy because then you'd only have miners owning it), then one would agree it's valueless economically, and you'd just have insane miners losing money for nothing.
Fiat is (usually) our current unit of account, even for things being sold for bitcoin. Read the book "Debt" to learn more about how something can be a unit of account EVEN AFTER IT ISN'T IN USE. So one could envisage a hyperbitcoinization world where people still price in dollars.
But I digress perhaps
reply
One would imagine that would be the case.
reply
It can only be spent as a medium of exchange if the counterparty believes that it is a sound store of value and will be worth something in the future.
reply
That seems inverted. People use shit fiat currencies all the time who have no faith in their future value. Medium of exchange is a pragmatic thing.
reply
If you accept fiat currency, it's because you believe that it will have value until you spend it.
reply
40 sats \ 0 replies \ @anon 21 Feb
Agreed. I think we as humans have a hard time accepting that two different things can be true at the same time. Perhaps embracing bitcoin as both at the same time to varying degrees represents our evolution as a species from “this or that” dualistic thinking to “nondual” thinking where we are able to hold the paradox.
reply
reply
Shit, I've been eating mine...
reply
Best answer
reply