You should read Herbert's description, if you want to be really confused about someone's placement.

Undisciplined

I think Geno and Purdy in the same tier after the 49ers disastrous season last year is pretty reasonable. I certainly wouldn't have Geno ahead and I don't really get the notion that Purdy had the 7th best PFF score for QBs in a down year with a team decimated by injuries but is the 11th best QB heading into the season. That seems like Cowherd logic.

Stacker_Sports

PFF Quarterback Rankings: All 32 starters ahead of the 2025 NFL season

I think Geno and Purdy in the same tier after the 49ers disastrous season last year is pretty reasonable. I certainly wouldn't have Geno ahead and I don't really get the notion that Purdy had the 7th best PFF score for QBs in a down year with a team decimated by injuries but is the 11th best QB heading into the season. That seems like Cowherd logic.  