Does legalising/decriminalising drugs work? \ stacker news ~AskSN

pull down to refresh

Does legalising/decriminalising drugs work?

699 sats \ 10 comments \ @stack_harder 8h AskSN

So it seems like Portugal is the poster child for this and, at a glance, seems very successful

Then on the other hand, I hear the places where drugs are legalised in Canada are like a hellscape, at least from an optics perspective.

I certainly wouldnt want to live anywhere near a place that was, basically, a magnet for drug users (skidrow levels)

what does Sn think?

view all related items

84 sats \ 5 replies \ @k00b 8h

Full disclosure, I've done very little research on the subject but I would guess it does work.

Despite how silly it sounds, I think a lot of drug use is a rebellion. It's cool to do prohibited things - for adults of all ages. It makes people that possess drugs part of an exclusive few. Legalizing them removes ALL cool points of drug possession. The only cool points left come from drugs being dangerous and their signal that you're "ready to die/destroy yourself for a good time."

Prohibition also makes drug users hide their usage which prevents intervention. We all know our friends that drink too much. But I'd guess most of us, unless we are users too, would fail to guess which of our friends use cocaine or other drugs.

Abrupt legalization likely needs to be paired with education, education that none of us get because it's assumed the state made sure we'll never encounter these drugs.

My bias here is that I think people should be allowed to do what they want with their bodies which could warp my perception of this topic entirely.

50 sats \ 1 reply \ @Aardvark 6h

Read "chasing the scream" it makes a very solid case for legalization. The outcomes for most people are generally positive, especially for addicts. More often than not their problems come from being in the system, not from being addicted. An example is that you don't see alcoholics committing crime for alcohol, they just go to work.

There's a whole lot more to it, but it's a fantastic read.

52 sats \ 0 replies \ @freetx 5h

Let me clarify to you and @thecommoner in case my short answer gave the wrong idea: I'm all for legalization. I dont think anyone has the right to forcibly stop someone from ingesting whatever they want....

There are some caveats of when people can ingest drugs (and to what degree): For instance, I think you would probably agree that it shouldn't be legal to drive blackout drunk? But we are not objecting to the act of ingesting the drug, rather its their inability to reasonably operate a dangerous device in public. It really has nothing to do with the drug....it should probably also be illegal to drive if physically blind or while sleeping, etc.

However the topic of legalization normally carries with it a sort of worst-case implication: Should it be legal for people to become addicted to drugs. For that I also think it should be legal, but well my point was simply: I think it should be legal but wouldn't define that as good strictly speaking. (Much in the same way I think it should be legal to chop your own hands off with an axe, but I wouldn't define that as good).

43 sats \ 1 reply \ @freetx 7h

I'm going to offer my equally un-researched take: I doubt legalizing drugs is a "good" for society, but its probably less bad than making them illegal.

Overall, societies would most benefit from govts fixing the core problem of: Why do members of their society so badly want to escape reality? Ultimately I think it goes something like this:

Poor economic possibilities -> Lack of home ownership + family + kids -> Lack of meaning -> Desire to escape.

21 sats \ 0 replies \ @thecommoner 6h

Also un-researched information...though I did read "Chasing the Scream" which is a book about addiction and I thought it offered good info...

I think society is looking at many of our "systems" coming to collapse under their own weight over the coming years...to maybe decades?

I am a weirdo in that I think all drugs should be legal and should be produced in a manner that is safe and reliable. Potency is something that should be verified and provided to the users so they are able to make educated decisions about what they are using.

I also believe the "stigma" we have created over drug use is a self-fullfilling negative prophecy in which users feel cast out from society and left alone to make their own ill-informed decisions on things. This perpetuates a cycle of more use due to feeling cast out and eventually leads to entire swaths of like-minded castaways that grow and grow until they become a blight on society and due to our years of mind-fucking the rest of society - those in power simply convince the rest of society that cutting these parts of society off is ok?

Anyway I am getting a bit off topic - It does come back to the "control system" that is put in place being out of alignment with the idea that we should be doing all we can as the "human race" to perpetuate our species...which includes acknowledging that as individuals we all have a right to do what we deem is best for ourselves, as long as it isn't harming others....that last part is the tough part....what one considers harming another?

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @LibertasBR 4h

I think a lot of drug use is a rebellion. It's cool to do prohibited things.

You couldn’t be more right about marijuana use. Just as ridiculous as the tobacco smokers from the ’20s and ’80s. Same goes for the other drugs too — it’s just that among all of them, weed and ecstasy carry this stronger kind of aura.

54 sats \ 0 replies \ @jannostr 2h freebie

Canadian here. Vancouver and Victoria, Canada are suffering dearly from this policy. It is very shortsighted. Drug related deaths are up, crime is up, and worst of all it takes the ability of parents to say there are consequences to using such drugs away from them. I fear the day my son comes to me and says, 'whatever dad, its not illegal.'

If you are interested in this topic, watch this documentary -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PT8OU8Yhs_s&t=731s. Aaaron Gunn, the person who made that film, is now a member of parliament in Canada.

101 sats \ 0 replies \ @Scoresby 6h

For a few years in my early twenties, I lived in the downtown eastside of Vancouver. I was working at a drop-in center for people with mental health issues and we served a lot of homeless and/or drug addicted people. At the time, harm reduction was the most popular approach to assisting such people. There were needle clinics and injection sites. I think it's fair to describe it as a magnet for drug users. It certainly was skid row.

Here's a few things I learned:

When you think of people nodding out on a street corner or collapsed on the sidewalk, it's pretty hard to tell the difference between drug addiction and mental illness. I knew plenty of people who were not into any particular drug use, but had equally miserable lives due to their severe mental health problems. Between the extremes of people who were legit nuts but not really into drugs and the people who were pretty neuro-normal but extreme down the addiction path, is the vast majority of homeless people -- probably using as a way to self-medicate.
Almost without exception, addicts in recovery had zero patience for harm reduction approaches. They strongly advocated zero-tolerance policies. It felt pretty harsh to me, but at the same time, I have to respect that these people had managed to extricate themselves from their drug use.
I can't really speak to drug use among people who aren't homeless. It seems that I don't run in the circles of drug users...or all the people I know are very secretive about it. Either way, my instincts tell me that the percentage of users among the "normal" population is probably not so different as the percentage of users among the homeless population.

So, legalizing drugs? I'm pretty much all for it on freedom principles. I doubt it dramatically increases or decreases the number of people you see nodded out on the side of the street.

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @bf53d2026e 46m freebie

Just

0 sats \ 0 replies \ @LibertasBR 3h

There’s no crime at all in using or selling drugs — those who buy, sell, and/or use are free to do as they wish. The crimes committed by users and dealers should be considered just like any other crimes. Here, dealers usually commit all three types: against freedom, property, and life. Users, most of the time, commit crimes against property.