pull down to refresh
75 sats \ 3 replies \ @BitcoinIsTheFuture OP 6 Apr \ parent \ on: BlackRock's Bitcoin ETF Broadens Reach, Securing 5 New Wall Street Banking APs econ
They have an agreement with 3rd party custodians for checks and balances outside of a few of them.
"Most spot Bitcoin ETFs rely on a third-party custodian to actually store the Bitcoin they hold — much like how spot gold ETFs often keep their physical gold holdings in the vault of a third-party custodian.
Eight out of the 10 currently-trading spot Bitcoin ETFs use Coinbase (COIN) as their Bitcoin custodian. The only exceptions are the Fidelity Wise Origin Bitcoin Fund (FBTC), which uses Fidelity itself as a custodian, and the VanEck Bitcoin Trust (HODL), which uses Gemini. "
source - https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/investing/spot-bitcoin-etf#:~:text=Most%20spot%20Bitcoin%20ETFs%20rely,COIN)%20as%20their%20Bitcoin%20custodian.
Next this article jumps in the the APs and Custodian relationships:
"When comparing the ‘In Kind’ and ‘In Cash’ redemption models for ETFs, various differences come to light. In the "In-Kind Redemption" model, APs can redeem ETF shares by directly receiving the underlying assets, typically Bitcoin, instead of cash. This process involves transferring a matching portfolio of securities to the ETF issuer, who then creates new ETF shares based on this portfolio, thereby avoiding immediate selling for cash. The benefits of this model include tax efficiency, liquidity maintenance, avoidance of market impact, creation/redemption flexibility, and transparency. However, considerations such as logistics, custodial challenges, and feasibility during extreme market conditions must be acknowledged."
source - https://www.coinbureau.com/education/how-bitcoin-etfs-work/
Yes. I understand the first part of your response. What confuses me regarding the APs is they can create shares of the etf with cash, without actually buying bitcoin. That seems clear. What is the mechanism ensuring that some entity (presumably BlackRock?) purchases actual bitcoin with that cash, and when? Can the price be manipulated in the interim? Moreover, how can BlackRock be sure about the number of shares created or redeemed by the AP? It seems like it would be easy if the AP was directly acquiring and selling the bitcoin to match the shares.
Maybe I'm just overly suspicious since I still don't like the ETFs to begin with.
reply
Yeah it’s confusing. I remember listening to a podcast with Preston Pysch I believe when he was questioning the structure and the 1-2 days to settle the transactions. It was complex. I can’t find it now though as I don’t see it under The Investors Podcast. He must have been on another one.
reply
deleted by author
reply