pull down to refresh

Apparently the Prime Clown in Canada is stepping down. Apparently the Orange Man beat the democrat machine. Are "we" winning? No.
I've had the illness of following politics for most of my life. I have never been less invested but I continue to see people missing the point. Several years ago there was an effort in California to remove Gavin Newsom from office. They call it a recall in the state.
When I hear people talk about Biden, or Newsom, or whoever you would think that all we need to do is vote the bum out and we are on the right path. That's way off. Trump's election isn't the goal but rather a sign of a minor shift in the culture and influence.
A mistake I see over and over again is focusing on the personalities. The puppets. The men. As if they are the problem. The problems are so much deeper. It's the culture, the programming, and the puppet masters. The problems are upstream of politicians. Remove one and another will replace them.
I don't so much care that Trump is less bad that Biden. Its that people make the mistake of focusing on the flag being blown by the wind than the wind itself. The politician is simply a result of many other more important factors.
Politicians work under an incentive structure that rewards promising things they cannot deliver. Even things that are not possible. Their only accountability is the voters and donors. The donors get what they want and the voters usually are to uninformed or dumb to realize what is going on. When they do realize it the other team is so demonized they either stick with their team or just don't vote.
The longer I look at democracy and the modern state the more absurd it appears to me. It's not that the men are bad or the government in power is bad. It's the whole incentive structure. There are almost no negative consequences pushing against this nonsense.
I have heard it said that the default view of political figures should be that of the tobacco executives. Today I think it should be the view of the medical insurance CEOs. The default view. There are exceptions but they are rare and work in spite of the system.
The solution is freedom and voluntary interaction. Removing the monopoly state. Remove the monopoly on violence. It would not be a utopia but IMO the incentives would be better.
The culture we create and the choices we make each day are making an impact. Remember that the flag doesn't control the wind. The wind controls the flag.
The longer I look at democracy and the modern state the more absurd it appears to me. It's not that the men are bad or the government in power is bad. It's the whole incentive structure.
Freakin well said!
Great post, thank you
reply
You know what's fascinating? Andrew Breitbart is famous for saying that "politics is downstream from culture", which I agree.
But last week, I heard Krystal Ball (a left leaning commentator) debate with her co-host Saagar Enjetti (a right leaning commentator) about the H1B controversy.
They were commenting on Vivek's comments about America's culture of entertainment & sports over academic achievement. Saager (an Indian-American) agrees with Vivek, but Krystal (a caucasian) disagreed that it was a cultural issue. And she said something along the lines of, "I don't think you can attribute it to culture. Our political and economic systems shape the culture."
So, two diametrically opposite views. One group thinks culture shapes politics, another thinks politics shapes culture. Could that explain some of the major discrepancies in worldview between the left and the right?
reply
Krystal is being naive
reply
Yes, she is very naive. But, as much as I disagree with many of her opinions, at least she is willing to talk to people who disagree with her without calling them racists.
reply
How low the bar has fallen that was once common is now rare.
reply
The bar is very low - this is the current reality for culture and politics
reply
That’s fair
reply
That is interesting but I do not think the right really gets how politics works. They might be closer to understanding than the left but the left is better at influencing culture. At least they have been in recent times(last 100 years).
reply
The reason I say the right doesn't get it is because they seem to focus more on elections and getting the "right" people in "power" than they do on culture.
I'd also add that politics does influence culture. I just don't think you can say it is the source. Both culture and politics influence each other.
reply
I agree that culture and politics both influence each other. And it's really tricky to define how a culture is shaped and what influences it.
reply
Culture affects children ie people who are not eligible to vote but already have opinions on abortion and guns and transgender craziness
Edit: On the other hand take a woke private school like Crossroads. The teachers and faculty order the children how to vote, who to vote for, who to demonize and hate. One reason the left succeeds beyond their numbers is they think about leftism 24/7. No days off
reply
It is a religion.
reply
Indeed
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Ge 6 Jan
wise words yeah I tell people all the time not to get so wrapped up in politics your putting too much of your trust into the state and people we all know man is not perfect so there will be corruption...and wrong doing especially if you have a corrupt seed as the reward
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Tef 6 Jan
Well said. Focusing on politicians as if they’re the root of the problem misses the bigger picture.
reply