pull down to refresh
20 sats \ 2 replies \ @south_korea_ln 14 Apr \ parent \ on: Ethical Collapse in the Peer Review of a Leading Vaccine Journal science
Do referee reports/names get published alongside published papers in your field? They are starting to do that in my field, but it's still at the opt-in level.
Do you think that the journals would do this? I am certain they will always pursue proper attribution, but not to peer-reviewer annotation, because, I understand, that they are supposed to remain anonymous, even when declaring conflicts of interest.
If they didn’t the peer-review process would become much more political than it is already.
reply
No, I haven't come across any journals in my field that do this. I'm not sure how much difference it would make unless the universities count referee contributions toward your tenure packet.
reply