In materials science, a disappearing polymorph is a form of a crystal structure that is suddenly unable to be produced, instead transforming into a different crystal structure with the same chemical composition (a polymorph) during nucleation.[2][3] Sometimes the resulting transformation is extremely hard or impractical to reverse, because the new polymorph may be more stable.[4] It is hypothesized that contact with a single microscopic seed crystal of the new polymorph can be enough to start a chain reaction causing the transformation of a much larger mass of material.[5] Widespread contamination with such microscopic seed crystals may lead to the impression that the original polymorph has "disappeared."
[...]
When the patent for paroxetine anhydrate (the "original" polymorph) ran out, other companies wanted to make generic antidepressants using the chemical. The only problem was that by the time other companies began manufacturing, Earth's atmosphere was already seeded with microscopic quantities of paroxetine hemihydrate from GSK's manufacturing plants, which meant that anyone trying to manufacture the original polymorph would find it transformed into the still-patented version, which GSK refused to give manufacturing rights for. As it is illegal to manufacture or sell anyone's patented product without their permission, GSK sued the Canadian generic pharmaceutical company Apotex (SmithKline Beecham Corp. v Apotex Corp) for patent infringement by producing quantities of the newer paroxetine polymorph in their generic pills, asking for their products to be blocked from entering the market.[10][7]
It's that second paragraph that is the crazy part...
reply
this seed crystal logic is so crazy
Although I have a hard time imagining all of earths atmosphere is the source of these seed crystals. And that they are unable to create an absolutely sterile environment from it. Theoretically they should only have to create their target seed crystals once, right? Idk, what do I know
reply
Based on reading about this issue I think one way to get around this problem has been to create an absolutely sterile environment. It's just really difficult and expensive.
reply
Exactly. And you'd have to keep it sterile even after creating it. Which is even more impractical.
reply
Yeah, I have a hard time wrapping my head around it.
My guess is that, even though they might be able to create a target crystal in a clean room, as soon as it starts being distributed around to customers, it can suffer from contamination from a single seed in the environment that triggers the transformation from the whole target crystal into the patented more stable crystal.
reply
This peer-reviewed article goes into more detail, but I don't have time to read it. In the Wikipedia page you cited it also mentions that some people believed it to be junk science or alchemy.
reply
Wow that is very interesting! Thanks for posting this.
reply
Thanks for sharing. Interesting and Informative
reply
Thanks to information