I'm quite confused about Full-RBF. None of the reasons advocating for Full-RBF really convinced me so far, and even the original DoS-protection use case by Antoine Riard doesn't seem so compelling now.
I get that policies are per node, but what Core enables matters. I also get that 0-conf isn't safe, but at least BIP0125 allowed for some risk management, which seems way more "opaque" with Full-RBF.
I also get that eventually all miners will apply Full-RBF to maximize revenue when rewards shrink, but does it justify pushing this hard for v24.0?
If you don't mind, please throw me your best arguments in favor or against Full-RBF. I've been doing my homework but it feels like I'm missing something.
(Note: this is duplicate from Twitter. Resposted here because I know that's where the best people are :)
mempoolfullrbf=1
on your home nodes, and mining nodes. It's better for everyone if we get rid of this opt-in-rbf/zeroconf nonsense.