pull down to refresh

I was going to write a post entitled "I would continue with the Carnivore diet just for this ONE benefit". But then thinking about it - I'll write that post tomorrow, since it would make much more sense to read that AFTER this one.
So here goes, as best as I can remember and jotted down in my notes - here's some of the most important improvements I've experienced over the past around 14 months.
Improved energy - this was huge, and the first thing I noticed. It came up at about 3 weeks, and not even 3 weeks of full carnivore, just mostly carnivore. Instead of just walking around the house, I was...bounding, zooming. Just moving with a lot more energy and zip. Memory - I remember things better. Things like pins, phone numbers, names, etc. Immune system - It's much improved! Before carnivore I would get nasty colds that would knock me out. This past year I had 1 minor cold, where I just kind of noticed, "Oh, I have a stuffy nose and sore throat - I must have a cold". But I experienced no decrease in energy level, or physical activity. Sunglasses - I don't need sunglasses anymore! The sun doesn't bother my eyes. I play sports in the sun, no sunglasses, when everyone else is wearing sunglasses. No more Hangry - The "hangry" experience doesn't happen anymore. If I miss a meal, it's not an emotional thing, that I get stressed about. I just get hungry. It's much easier to skip a meal, if need be. Gas - Zero gas. That's unless I have heavy whipping cream, which I sometimes do, that gives me gas. Less mental fog - I think more clearly. Just like how in the physical realm, I have more energy - I also have more energy in the mental realm. Better balance. I didn't feel unsteady before, but I think there were little age-related balance issues. Now gone. Posture - It feels much more natural to stand completely straight and not slouch Insomnia - it's now absolutely gone. I wasn't very much troubled by it before, but maybe every week or 2 I'd have an episode where I would wake up at night and not be able to go to sleep again for 2, 3 hours. That's completely gone. Air hunger - I previously had a growing problem with something called "air hunger" or dyspnea. Just the feeling of not being able to get a full, complete breath. I had done some research on it, it was probably some aging/metabolic issue. That's completely gone now. Hair - my hair is growing in thicker "Carnivore calm" - I've heard this term on podcasts, and it really applies to me. I just don't get that riled up about things. Problems happen, sure, and they bother me, but in general I deal with them better. My anxiety level is way down. Strange things - Just oddball things. For instance, I had noticed that my typing speed had, very, very slowly, degraded over the years. Just a consequence of aging, I thought. But now it's much faster again, maybe to as fast as I was a couple decades ago. Something similar is - emptying the dishwasher. I'm weirdly fast and efficient at sorting out big piles of cutlery, and getting the whole thing done in under a few minutes. Zero social anxiety - I wasn't terrible before carnivore. But I have even less social anxiety now. For instance, I was just at a conference, and sitting next to some people I'd barely met. They were making lunch plans, and I had already had lunch. But I wanted to talk to them some more, and asked if I could join them. It turned out great, I had great conversations and got to know them better. I really don't think I would have done that before carnivore. Aches and pains - Weird little aches and pains have disappeared. I'm not completely free of aches and pains, but they're definitely diminished More agile - I'm better at sports. I play pickleball regularly, and a few months into it, people were commenting on my improvements.
Here's some of my older posts on Carnivore in "newest first" order, just for completeness:
This is an interesting list, thanks for sharing it. I've heard many such good reports, especially w/ people w/ auto-immune issues that resisted other therapies.
While I believe your report, and the others I have heard, a confound that has often been difficult to assess is the anything is better than the shit that I've been doing confound. In other words, the standard Western diet is so bad that it might as well be an attack on health. (I don't often use language this extreme about stuff, where everything is "an attack" on something or other, but believe it to be warranted in this case.)
So my question to you is: what's the control group? Where were you starting from? What (if any) results have you historically achieved from other principled diets aside from carnivore?
Hope you take this the right way; just trying to understand the larger context. You've posted a bunch of older stuff, and probably the answers are in there someplace -- if you could recommend one to start with I'll have a look myself.
reply
Very good question. And here's the thing - my previous diet was, according to the "standard US nutritional advice", absolutely GREAT.
Really, it was way "better" than almost everyone I know.
  • I seriously limited meat. I favored chicken a LOT over beef, and when making a recipe, I would do things like cut in half the amount of meat. Or at least, reduce it a little bit. I fully believed the whole thing about using meat as a "condiment".
  • loads and loads of whole grains. Rarely anything not whole grain. Ground my own wheat flour from wheat grains at home
  • ate tons of "superfoods". Like Chia, Spinach, flax, etc. Turns out that crap is terrible for you.
  • NEVER at least for the past ... 7 years or so, did I eat processed junk food. I did have some "junk food", but it was all homemade (cookies, popcorn, etc). And I had to limit that, in order to not gain weight.
  • I didn't pig out on carbs, in general. One of my rules at restaurants was to NEVER eat any of the stuff that they brought to the table (bread, usually) before the main meal.
  • Not only did I not eat processed junk food in the form of Cheetos, purchased ice cream, etc, I also never ate any junk food in the form of fancy treats from bakeries or anything similar.
  • I never ate ANY fried food. That was one of my rules.
  • Every meal had lots of fruits and vegetables.
  • I weight myself regularly, and was always a healthy weight, and at the low side of a healthy weight. Also exercised regularly - not as much as some, but definitely very regular.
  • really avoided saturated fat. Believed in the garbage idea that canola oil and vegetable oil are better than animal fats.
I think that's the gist of it. Previous that the period I'm describing, maybe about past 7 years before carnivore, my eating habits were more "average healthy diet" and not as "extreme".
So when I read the Nina Teicholtz book "The Big Fat Surprise", it was a completely, mind blowing revelation for me. I thought I was doing the best thing ever, turns out my diet was rotten. Way too many carbs, not nearly enough meat and animal fats, and too much veggie/fruit.
Though it was maybe better than what other people were doing, my diet still sucked.
Yes, I'm a true believer in Carnivore. Stay tuned for my post tomorrow.
reply
One more thing - no autoimmune disorders, or really anything like that.
That's why I'm a little bit of an oddball in the carnivore world - many people who go carnivore have autoimmune disorders, or something else serious. I was fairly healthy. Not as healthy as I wanted to be, though.
reply
Great context, thank you. Look fwd to tmrw's post!
reply
You're a carnivore maxi!
Isn't carnivore diet low in vitamin c, folate and has no fiber?
I seriously doubt when someone claims to live on carnivore diet exclusively.
reply
If people needed the standard recommended amounts of vitamin C on a carnivore diet, then Eskimos, as a people, wouldn't exist. Think about it, they only ate meat and fish, and maybe trace amounts of berries, only in the summer. Meanwhile, sailors on long trips sometimes got scurvy in about 6 weeks. Why? They had a very high carb diet.
There's lots of videos out there on why people don't get scurvy on a carnivore diet, take a look at them and see what you think.
reply
Eskimos ate almost everything out of meat and they also ate lot of berries even in winters. Ask a Eskimos for their diet, it's not very similar to what most carnivore maxis suggest.
reply
"Ask an Eskimo for their diet"....hmm. Yeah, that's not easy. And besides, we're talking about the ancestral diet for Eskimos, not their current diet, which is probably more like the standard American diet.
But if you want to look at some anthropological reports of what they ate, before they had "modern" foods, look at this book - My Life with the Eskimo, by Vilhjalmur Stefansson. It's available here: https://annas-archive.org/md5/eec5a2359ef12238d79a94317989b6f6. Basically, plant food was EXTREMELY limited and negligible as a source of calories.
Here's an excerpt, specifically about the usage of plants by the Eskimo.
The only roots which I have seen used as food by the Eskimo are the roots of a species of Knotweed — either Polygonum bistortum (Tourn.) L., Polygonum viviparum L., or Polygonum fugax Small. The roots of plants of this genus, known to the Eskimo as Mā’sū, or Mā’shū, are frequently dug and eaten in summer, but usually only when there is a scarcity of meat or fish for food. These roots are fairly edible, either raw or cooked, having a slightly sweetish taste, but are somewhat woody and fibrous. On the Colville River, Alaska, the Eskimo preserve the Masu roots in sealskin “pokes,” and eat them in a somewhat fermented state. Several species of small ground-growing berries are often eaten by the western Eskimo, particularly a yellow berry called Ak’pek (the Cloudberry, Ruhus chamoemarus Linn.), the At’tsi-ak (Alpine Bearberry, Mairania alpina (Linn.) Desv.), and the paun’rat (Crowberry, Evipetrum nigrum Linn.). These berries are eaten by the Coronation Gulf Eskimo, except the akpek, the use of which is unknown, although in the opinion of white men and of the western Eskimo it is the best of all local berries. They are eaten by the Mackenzie Eskimo, but they say they did not use them extensively until taught to do so by the Alaskan Eskimo (not more than twenty-five years ago). The leaves of Oxyria digyna (L.), a species of sorrel, are frequently mixed with seal-oil and eaten as a sort of salad by the western Eskimo. The plant is called Ko’na-ritj by Alaskan Eskimo. The partly digested stomach contents of the Barren Ground caribou are frequently eaten frozen in winter. Stomachs filled with reindeer-moss are considered much better than those from caribou which have been feeding on the coarse, woody fibers of grassy plants. As with most other viands, this dish is not considered complete without a liberal dressing of seal-oil.
reply
21 sats \ 2 replies \ @IamSINGLE 2h
So, you accept they needed fibre and they knew how to get it. I'm pretty sure, you also know how you getting it. TBH, I'm not against carnivore diet but I only can't think of how people can live off without some of the essential nutrients. A balanced diet is what I'd prefer.
reply
I'm not quite sure how you got this, "you accept they needed fibre".
234 sats \ 4 replies \ @Fabs 13h
Oh come on man, eating more meat reduces social anxiety?!
That list reads like those "no-fap" guys over at Reddit where they share their newfound "superpowers" because they don't ejaculate anymore, yet the only proven change that occurs while doing that, is an increased chance of developing testicular cancer.
reply
Here's my thoughts - eating mostly animal products and mostly avoiding plants not only reduces social anxiety, it reduces ALL anxiety. The social anxiety thing was just my most recent example.
Just like eating carnivore can heal many issues in your body, it also can heal many issues in your brain. And excessive anxiety - unproductive anxiety - is a brain problem.
Check out Dr Georgia Ede's book, Change Your Diet, Change Your Mind. It's really great, and deals mostly with how a carnivore diet, or even just reduced carb diet, can really help mental health dramatically.
Here's a quote.
Between 2007 and 2018, while I was serving as a psychiatrist at Harvard University and then at Smith College, my seasoned colleagues and I observed a most disturbing trend: It was becoming increasingly common for first-year students to arrive on campus already taking one, two, or even three psychiatric medications. Requests for specialized support for learning and emotional disabilities were rising so fast that it was difficult to accommodate everyone’s needs. More and more students were showing up at campus mental health clinics in crisis, requiring emergency psychiatric hospitalizations, leaves of absence, or academic withdrawals. The sense among clinicians on the front lines is that the mental health of our young people is increasingly brittle, and research supports our observations.
While ... physical and mental health conditions may seem unrelated to each other, they commonly occur together and share many of the same underlying abnormalities, the most important being inflammation, oxidative stress, and insulin resistance.24
Inflammation and oxidative stress are part of your immune system’s first responder network, so it is normal and healthy to have a certain degree of both, but excessive inflammation and oxidative stress can be very damaging to every cell in the body—and brain cells are no exception.
Insulin resistance (which is often called “prediabetes”) is a common metabolic disorder in which insulin doesn’t work as well as it should. If you have insulin resistance, your body will need to produce more than the usual amount of insulin to try to keep your blood sugar (and brain sugar) levels stable and in a healthy range, so your insulin levels will tend to run too high. Over time, high insulin levels can make it more difficult for your brain to turn glucose (blood sugar) into energy.
It just so happens that our industrially ultraprocessed diet is a powerful promoter of inflammation, oxidative stress, and insulin resistance—all of which are just as dangerous for the brain as they are for the rest of the body. In the long search for biological root causes of mental illness—a search that has been focused almost exclusively on neurotransmitters for nearly seventy-five years—inflammation, oxidative stress, and insulin resistance have emerged as an unholy trinity of destructive forces that help to explain why those neurotransmitter imbalances occur.
We readily accept that diet plays a major role in the health of the rest of the body—why should the brain be any different? The foods we eat provide the construction materials we need to build healthy, resilient brain cells and the fuel we need to energize them. If we don’t eat the right foods, none of our cells will develop or function properly, and any number of things can and will go wrong—including many things no medication can address.
Medications can and do change brain chemistry, and they have their place, but I’m convinced that the most powerful way to change brain chemistry is through food, because that’s where brain chemicals come from in the first place. Neurotransmitters are made from food, the brain cells that pass them back and forth to communicate with each other are made from food, and even the salty soup that surrounds them is made from food. Optimal mental health requires that your whole brain be made of the right stuff, so if you have a mental (or physical) health problem of any kind, the first place to look isn’t your medicine cabinet, it’s your pantry. This advice holds true whether you view mental health conditions as primarily biologically driven or psychosocially driven, because, as we’ll see in the coming chapters, the way we eat has a profound impact on brain development, neurotransmitters, stress hormones, inflammation, antioxidant capacity, brain energy production, brain aging, and brain healing.
There is only so much you can do to reduce your exposure to stress, and nothing you can do to change the genes you were born with or the childhood you experienced, but you can change your diet—and changing your diet can change your mind.
reply
0 sats \ 2 replies \ @Fabs 12h
I'd concur that the mental health issues pointed out in the above quote are -imo- at least in part correlated to the rise of social media.
I don't really "get" the link between food and thought; What I think and what I eat are two different things, no? I can eat healthy and have a depression at the same time, no?
reply
I can sense you have a lot of skepticism about carnivore. I did as well, before I got interested in bitcoin. I had heard of it, just a little, and it sounded absolutely INSANE to me.
But then I learned that some bitcoiners that I really respected were carnivore. That opened my mind. Then I listened to an interview with Nina Teicholtz, and it was so fascinating that decided I absolutely HAD to read her book The Big Fat Surprise.
I read the book, and it turned my (nutritional) world upside down. I continued reading other books with alternative nutritional approaches, and started listening to carnivore podcasts.
Then within a month I was actually carnivore. And have been doing it for 14 months, and will absolutely never go back.
reply
0 sats \ 0 replies \ @Fabs 9h
I mean if it works for you it works, but some of your experiences are a bit of a stretch to me.
reply
"Carnivore calm" - I've heard this term on podcasts, and it really applies to me. I just don't get that riled up about things. Problems happen, sure, and they bother me, but in general I deal with them better. My anxiety level is way down.
That is wonderful.
I cheat a lot these days (especially with gf at home, eating lots of vegetables and pancakes etc) so I don't notice the positive, long-time effects so much anymore. What I do notice is exactly this—after eating a big steak, everything is just calm and balances, emotionally and spiritually.
Funny too about physical balance. That's why I got so good so fast?? (#864752)
reply
Posture is a new benefit for me to hear! Thanks for sharing!
reply
Sounds like it’s been great for you!
reply